It seems Milo Ventimiglia isn’t a very big fan of used goods. Just a week after sources spotted Hayden Panettiere hooking up with Jesse McCartney in a club, sources close to Hayden and Milo have come forward saying that the pair have called it quits.

The Heroes co-stars with the 12-year age gap had been dating for over a year, and reportedly split over Hayden’s Hollywood partying ways. Apparently the only clubs Milo frequented involved stormtroopers and superheros.